Burnt Mills Highballers
Square Dance Banner

Upcoming Shows

Date City Address Time
January 9, 2026 Frenchtown, NJ Wild Fern Brewing, 62A Trenton Ave 6:30 pm
January 23, 2026 Milford, NJ The Farm House Inn, 425 Milford Warren Glen Rd 7:30 pm
January 24, 2026 Frenchtown, NJ Square Dance at American Legion, Harrison St 6:00 pm
January 28, 2026 Milford, NJ Old Time Jam at Descendants Brewing, 61 Bridge St 6:30 pm
February 13, 2026 Milford, NJ The Farm House Inn, 425 Milford Warren Glen Rd 7:30 pm
February 21, 2026 Frenchtown, NJ Square Dance at American Legion, Harrison St 6:00 pm
March 5, 2026 Wayne, PA 118 North w/ Larry Keel Experience, 118 N Wayne Ave 7:00 pm
March 21, 2026 Frenchtown, NJ Square Dance at American Legion, Harrison St 6:00 pm

Band Members

Instrument Name
Bass/Banjo UkeCaitlin Pyne
FiddleMike Haller
GuitarSally Sam Heller
BanjoTom Malle
3 Finger BanjoRuss Gottlieb
GuitarRich Kiley
MandolinLucas Pick
BassDave Brumberg

Where our name comes from?

Milford, NJ used to be called Burnt Mills after a large fire in 1769. While "highball" comes from the old-fashioned train signal meaning full speed, originating from raising a ball to the top of a mast.

In the 1920s the Blue Ridge Highballers out of Danville, Virginia were playing and recording music, and then the Ozark Highballers out of Fayetteville, Arkansas began in 2014 with some of the best old-time harmonica you’ll ever hear.

The artwork at the top of our website was drawn by local artist Ethan Stuart. It depicts the 1877 trainwreck described like this:

"One of the greatest disasters in the history of the local division of the Pennsylvania Railroad occurred here on the evening of October 4, 1877. Heavy rains turned the Quequacommissicong creek into a raging torrent. The rushing stream undermined and washed away a section of the stone culvert over which the Oswego and Philadelphia Express had to pass. When the train reached this point, the locomotive No. 142 plunged into the abyss, followed by the baggage and two passenger coaches."

In conclusion, we are a fiery trainwreck.

Videos by Poppy Don

Poppy Don is Caitlin's grandpa and his entire youtube channel is videos of us!

Visit Poppy Don's YouTube channel  |  View the full Burnt Mills playlist